Skip to main content
Silver Streak Education banner: What I Learned Watching Scam Victims Walk Through Our Doors, by Sherri L. Combs, with a portrait of Sherri seated in an office.
Fraud Prevention & Safety

I Was a JPMorgan Chase Private Banker. Here's What I Learned Watching Scam Victims Walk Through Our Doors.

A former private banker's perspective on fraud, trust, and prevention

Scam victims aren't foolish. They're convinced. A former JPMorgan Chase private banker shares what she saw at the bank, why warnings so often fail, and how the PROVE IT™ Method helps people stop and ask one more question.

Estimated reading time
9 min read
Designed for
Older Adults, Families & Caregivers
Written by
Sherri L. Combs

There is something heartbreaking about watching someone lose their life savings when you can see the danger coming, but they cannot.

I know because I spent years on the other side of the banking desk.

During my career as a private banker with JPMorgan Chase, I saw firsthand what financial exploitation does to people. I also witnessed the extraordinary efforts bankers and branch managers made to protect customers who were convinced they were making the right decisions.

And I learned something that fundamentally changed the direction of my life.

By the time many scam victims walk through a bank's doors, the criminal has already done the most important part of the work.

They have captured the victim's trust.

Sometimes they have captured something even more powerful: their hope.

They Weren't Foolish. They Were Convinced.

One of the greatest misconceptions about scams is that only gullible or uninformed people fall for them.

I can tell you from experience that simply isn't true.

I saw attorneys, accountants, insurance professionals, business owners, and highly educated individuals become entangled in elaborate schemes.

I saw men and women in their forties who believed they had discovered extraordinary investment opportunities. I saw retirees who were convinced they were about to receive the financial breakthrough they had been waiting for.

Some were financially sophisticated. Others had very little experience with investments.

Some were wealthy. Others were struggling to make their mortgage payments.

They came from different backgrounds, professions, political beliefs, and economic circumstances.

But there was something many of them shared.

They didn't believe they were being scammed. They believed they were finally being given an opportunity.

And in some cases, they believed the banker standing in front of them was the person preventing them from taking advantage of it.

Scammers Don't Have to Change Your Beliefs. They Exploit the Ones You Already Have.

This is one of the most disturbing patterns I witnessed.

Financial predators are extraordinarily skilled at understanding what motivates people.

If someone is deeply religious, the appeal may come wrapped in the language of faith, generosity, blessings, or divine timing.

If someone believes strongly in manifestation or the power of positive thinking, the message may promise abundance, financial transformation, or a breakthrough that's just around the corner.

If someone participates in political communities or alternative investment discussions, scammers may use familiar personalities, slogans, currencies, or supposedly exclusive information to create credibility.

And if someone is lonely, grieving, frightened, or desperate for financial relief, the criminal may offer companionship, reassurance, security, or hope.

The specific belief system is not the problem. Nor does participating in a particular religious, political, or spiritual community mean someone is destined to be scammed.

The problem is that dishonest people can use the language of those communities to manufacture trust.

I remember encounters with customers who were convinced that unusual currencies, novelty financial instruments, or promised monetary resets would soon transform their futures.

They had watched videos, joined groups, followed discussions, and listened to people who spoke with absolute certainty.

By the time they came to the bank, they weren't merely considering an investment.

They had often built an entire emotional future around it.

And challenging the transaction sometimes felt, to them, like challenging their intelligence, their beliefs, and everything they were hoping for.

The fraud wasn't simply financial anymore. It had become personal.

When Hope Becomes the Hook

I also saw the devastating consequences of financial exploitation through relationships built on trust.

Sometimes those relationships began in churches, faith communities, investment groups, or other places where people naturally seek belonging and encouragement.

Most people in these communities are sincere. But a bad actor who gains trust can sometimes use that credibility to exploit others.

I encountered people who were struggling to afford basic necessities but remained determined to send money to someone who had convinced them that giving more would eventually bring blessings, prosperity, or relief.

The circumstances varied, but the emotional mechanism was often familiar.

Give a little more.

Wait a little longer.

Have more faith.

Don't listen to the doubters.

Your breakthrough is coming.

And when nothing happened, the victim was sometimes told the problem wasn't the promise.

The problem was that they hadn't believed enough, sacrificed enough, or waited long enough.

That is a particularly destructive kind of manipulation because it shifts responsibility away from the person making the promise and onto the person being exploited.

It keeps people emotionally invested even when the evidence suggests they should walk away.

I Watched Bankers Beg People Not to Send Their Money

There are moments from my banking career that have never left me.

I remember bankers and managers trying desperately to reason with customers who wanted to send suspicious wire transfers.

They would ask questions. Explain warning signs. Encourage customers to reconsider. Sometimes they would ask them to slow down, speak with someone they trusted, or take more time before making an irreversible decision.

And still, some customers insisted.

They were adults. It was their money. And they believed they knew exactly what they were doing.

Financial institutions have important fraud detection responsibilities, but they also operate within legal, regulatory, privacy, and customer-authority boundaries. Those safeguards matter, even when they complicate intervention.

Sometimes a banker could recognize the warning signs but could not simply take control of a customer's financial decisions or disclose private information to family members without an appropriate legal basis.

And sometimes the customer viewed every warning as further evidence that the supposedly extraordinary opportunity was being kept from them.

Then came the return visit.

Days or weeks later, someone would walk back through the doors, often devastated.

The investment never materialized.

The person they trusted had disappeared.

Their savings were gone.

And the question was always some version of the same thing.

"Is there anything you can do to get it back?"

Those were among the hardest conversations.

Recovery is sometimes possible, especially when fraud is reported immediately. Banks may be able to attempt wire recalls, and law enforcement may be able to intervene or trace funds.

But time matters enormously. Once funds move through multiple accounts or across international borders, recovery can become exceedingly difficult.

I saw the human cost behind those transactions.

Not just lost dollars.

Lost independence. Lost security. Lost confidence.

And for older adults, sometimes the loss of money they were counting on to pay for housing, food, medication, and care for the rest of their lives.

The Most Dangerous Moment Is When Someone Stops Asking Questions

Over time, I came to understand that many sophisticated scams are not built around a single lie.

They are built around a sequence of emotional commitments.

The criminal makes contact and establishes familiarity.

They learn what the person wants, fears, values, or hopes to achieve.

They build trust through repeated interactions.

They create a sense of belonging or privileged access.

Then they introduce urgency, secrecy, or a reason to distrust anyone who questions the opportunity.

Eventually, the victim may begin defending the person exploiting them.

Family members become obstacles.

Bankers become obstacles.

Law enforcement becomes an obstacle.

Anyone who challenges the story is treated as someone who simply doesn't understand.

I think of this as a form of mental hijacking: a state in which emotional pressure, manipulation, and accumulated commitment make it extraordinarily difficult for someone to evaluate the situation independently.

It's my descriptive term for what I witnessed, not a clinical diagnosis.

And I believe it helps explain why telling someone, "That's a scam," often isn't enough.

Sometimes that warning only makes them dig in deeper.

What they need is an opportunity to interrupt the pressure, regain perspective, and begin asking questions again.

We Need to Reach People Before the Criminals Do

JPMorgan Chase invested in educating its bankers to recognize suspicious activity, identify warning signs, and help protect customers.

That training influenced me profoundly.

But I kept coming back to a question.

What if the customer had received that education before the scammer ever contacted them?

What if they understood emotional manipulation before someone used it against them?

What if they recognized the warning signs of financial exploitation before their money was at risk?

What if families had practical tools for starting conversations without making their loved ones feel embarrassed, judged, or attacked?

In corporate America, employees routinely receive cybersecurity and fraud awareness training. Many organizations conduct simulated phishing exercises to help employees recognize suspicious links and requests.

Yet outside the workplace, millions of older adults and families must navigate increasingly sophisticated scams without the benefit of comparable, recurring training.

Public education resources do exist, including excellent work by government agencies, financial institutions, and community organizations.

But we need to make that education more accessible, more practical, and more consistent.

We need to move beyond merely telling people that scams exist.

We need to teach people what to do when a scam is happening to them.

Why I Created the PROVE IT™ Method

Those experiences became part of the inspiration behind Silver Streak and the PROVE IT™ Method.

I wanted to create something practical. Something memorable. Something people could use in the moment, especially when emotions were running high.

Our message is simple:

Before you open it, click it, buy it, wire it, or believe it, make them PROVE IT.

The method begins with five actions:

P — Pause. Interrupt the urgency. Stop before clicking, responding, or transferring money.

R — Read. Look closely at the message, promise, request, or opportunity. What are the warning signs? What doesn't make sense?

O — Outreach. Talk with someone you trust who isn't involved in the transaction or relationship. Invite another perspective.

V — Verify. Independently confirm the claims using contact information and sources you find yourself, not those supplied by the person making the request.

E — End. If something cannot be verified, stop the interaction. Don't send money, share sensitive information, or continue engaging.

The purpose isn't to make people suspicious of everyone.

It's to give them permission to slow down.

Because when someone is being pressured to act immediately, a pause can be one of the most powerful protections available.

And when an older parent or loved one appears caught in a scam, our first response shouldn't necessarily be an argument.

It should be curiosity.

"Can we look at this together?"

"How do we know this person is who they say they are?"

"What would happen if we waited until tomorrow?"

"Could we call the organization directly and verify that?"

Sometimes the first victory isn't convincing someone that they're wrong.

It's helping them become willing to ask one more question.

The Cost Is Far Greater Than the Money

According to the FBI's 2025 Internet Crime Complaint Center report, Americans aged 60 and older filed more than 201,000 complaints, reporting approximately $7.7 billion in losses.

Those figures represent reported cyber-enabled fraud alone.

Behind each report is a person.

A retirement interrupted.

A home that may be at risk.

A family relationship strained by secrecy, embarrassment, or financial loss.

An older adult who may no longer have the years or earning capacity necessary to rebuild what was taken.

We absolutely need law enforcement, financial institutions, regulators, and stronger protections. Criminal accountability matters.

But laws alone cannot educate people in the moment when a predator approaches them.

And arresting a criminal after the money is gone doesn't necessarily restore a victim's future.

Prevention has to become a larger part of our national response.

From Private Banking to Senior Advocacy

I never imagined that my experiences in private banking would eventually lead me to build a national senior advocacy platform and a nonprofit dedicated to protecting older adults.

But I couldn't forget the people I'd encountered.

Today, through Silver Streak Senior Services, Silver Streak Senior Solutions, my speaking engagements, and educational workshops, I work to help older adults and families recognize fraud, prepare for aging, and find trustworthy resources before a crisis.

We are also exploring ways to bring practical fraud prevention education into more community organizations, law enforcement partnerships, and financial institutions.

My goal is not to replace the extraordinary work already happening in banking and law enforcement.

It's to help extend that protection beyond the bank's doors.

Because the best time to protect someone's life savings is before a criminal convinces them to give it away.

And the best time to educate a family is before they're standing in a bank lobby, desperately trying to recover what they've lost.

One Question I Hope You'll Ask Today

Think about someone you love.

A parent. A spouse. A friend. A neighbor. A colleague.

If they received a convincing call, investment opportunity, romantic message, or urgent request for money tomorrow, would they know what to do?

Would they recognize the emotional manipulation?

Would they feel comfortable asking for help?

Would they know how to verify the story before acting?

And perhaps most importantly, would they trust you enough to tell you what was happening before it was too late?

That's where prevention begins.

Not with fear.

Not with shame.

But with education, conversation, and the practical tools to make safer decisions.

We cannot stop every scammer from trying. But we can do much more to prepare people before they're targeted.

And after everything I witnessed during my banking career, I believe that's a mission worth pursuing.

Learn more about fraud prevention, the PROVE IT™ Method, and helpful resources at silverstreakhelp.com. Speaking and media inquiries: sherricombs.com.

Quick Questions

Are scam victims usually careless or uninformed?

Sherri Combs writes that this is one of the greatest misconceptions she saw as a private banker. The people she watched were not foolish. They were convinced. Scammers are skilled at using the beliefs, hopes, and relationships a person already has.

Why do warnings from a bank often fail in the moment?

By the time someone is standing at a teller window to send a wire, they have often made a series of emotional commitments. The most dangerous moment is when a person stops asking questions. Bankers can beg a customer not to send the money and still be unable to break that conviction in a single conversation.

What kinds of relationships do scammers exploit?

The article describes relationships built on trust and hope — sometimes beginning in churches, faith communities, investment groups, or other places where people naturally look for belonging. The hook is often hope, not a clumsy lie.

What should I do instead of arguing with someone who is already convinced?

Reach people earlier, and give them a simple way to pause before money moves. That experience is part of why Sherri created the PROVE IT Method. If you are the person being pressed to send money, stop and verify independently before you act. If you love someone who may be in a scam, stay calm, keep the door open, and use our guide on how to help someone escape a romance scam when that is the situation.

Is the harm only financial?

No. The article emphasizes that the cost is far greater than the money. The emotional aftereffects, the loss of confidence, and the strain on family relationships can last long after a wire is gone. Reporting is still worthwhile, and there is no shame in asking for help.

About the Author

Sherri L. Combs

Founder & CEO, Silver Streak Senior Services

Sherri L. Combs is a former JPMorgan Chase private banker, award-winning and bestselling author of The Just-In-Case Plan, national senior advocacy leader, and keynote speaker. She is the Founder and CEO of Silver Streak™ Senior Services and President of Silver Streak Senior Solutions, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit focused on fraud prevention education and supporting older adults.

Trusted Resources

  • Fraud Prevention
  • Scams
  • Financial Exploitation
  • PROVE It Method